A breakdown of selected government surveillance programs. Prior to the revelations, several senators warned that the doj was using section 215 of the patriot act to support what government attorneys called a sensitive collection program, targeting large numbers of americans. In 2018, under only one of two section 215 provisions, the government collected 434,238,543 call records. This report tells you where it came from, whats going on now, and what congress needs to know before it considers reauthorizing the law. Section 215 of the usa patriot act has been used to collect, in bulk, telephony metadata of u. The government could even try to use section 215 for bulk collection of financial or other business records. Many libraries posted signs like this, warning patrons about the usa patriot act.
Section 215 allows the government to obtain a secret court order requiring third parties, such as telephone companies, to hand. The report contains descriptive, legal, and policy analyses of both the telephone records program and the fisa court, and it. Section 215 of the patriot act section 215 of the usa patriot act allows the government to obtain a secret order from the foreign intelligence surveillance court fisc requiring third parties like telephone companies to hand over any records or other tangible thing if deemed relevant to an international terrorism, counterespionage, or. Overview of section 215 section 215 of the usa patriot act. Under the patriot act, it is a federal crime to commit dangerous and illegal acts on u. Section 2332b and the material support sections of title 18. Access to records and other items under the foreign intelligence surveil lance act. Woods the usa patriot act1 has sparked intense public debate, with proponents claiming that the act is a necessarily hardminded response to a national crisis,2 while opponents see unwarranted, even opportunistic. Specifically, the section of the patriot act that expired is section 215, which is commonly nicknamed the library records provision, because it called on librarians to hand over patron. The fbi and nsa use section 215 to collect vast amounts of information about us persons without a warrant. Assessment of progress in implementing recommendations and examination of use in 2007 through 2009 author. Section 2332e of title 18, united states code, is amended.
Congress charged pclob with analyzing actions the executive branch takes to protect the u. A practical history of usa patriot act section 215 michael j. Postpatriot act, thirdparty holders of your financial, library, travel, video rental, phone, medical, church, synagogue, and mosque records. Section 215, also known as the tangible things or business records provision of the usa patriot act, amended section 501 of the foreign intelligence surveillance act and permits the collection of tangible things including books, records, papers, documents, and other items for an investigation to obtain foreign intelligence information the collection of such items is permitted if the investigation seeks to obtain foreign intelligence information that does. In a resolution passed on june 29, 2005, they stated that section 215 of the usa patriot act allows the government to secretly request and obtain library records for large numbers of individuals without any reason to believe they are involved in illegal activity. This white paper explains the governments legal basis for an intelligence collection program under which the federal bureau of investigation fbi obtains court orders directing certain telecommunications service providers to produce telephony metadata in bulk. Report on the telephone call records program conducted under section 215. Broad coalition calls for patriot act surveillance reform. Support our response to covid19 your gift will fund our critical work to protect voting rights, demand that vulnerable people in prisons, jails and immigration detention centers be released, and fight to ensure reproductive health care remains open and accessible to all who need it. However, none of these compliance issues involved significant intentional misuse of the system.
Letter from civil liberties groups to house judiciary committee on the use of section 215 of the patriot act. This provision has served as a legal basis for the governments controversial collection of bulk telephone metadata. Section 215 of the patriot act and metadata collection. References to, and modification of short title for, usa patriot act. Fbis use of section 215 orders doj oig department of justice. Mass surveillance under section 215 of the usa patriot actusa freedom act. Section 215 of the patriot act is set to expire on june 1, 2015. It passed in the senate by a vote of 981 and in the house of representatives by 35766. These records reveal personal details about peoples lives, like whom. Patriot act wex us law lii legal information institute.
Usa patriot act title iii international money laundering. The usa freedom act of 2015 bans the bulk collection of americans private records under section 215 of the usa patriot act. Usa patriot is an acronym for uniting and strengthening america by providing appropriate. Shortly after bulk collection of cdrs was disclosed in 20, the government made numerous and misleading claims about the efficacy of section 215 in stopping terrorist attacks. Foreign intelligence surveillance court fisa court for any tangible things. Section 215 of the usa patriot act electronic frontier. Moreover, section 1001 of the usa patriot act requires the departments. Section 215 of the usa patriot act 2001 expanded the foreign intelligence surveillance act fisa authority for seizing business records. Illegal, overbroad, and unnecessary june 19, 20 an order of the super secret foreign intelligence surveillance court fisc that came to light on june 5 has lead to revelations that the national security agency nsa has for seven years been. In 2018, under only one of two section 215 provisions. Nsa fact sheet on section 702 of fisa and section 215 of. Text of the usa patriot act american civil liberties union. Some sections of the original law were deleted or amended. Section 215 fact sheet section 215 of the usa patriot act.
Along with two other patriot act provisions, section 215 lapsed after lawmakers failed to reach an agreement on a broader set of reforms to the foreign intelligence surveillance act fisa. In the years following the patriot acts passage shortly after the terrorist attacks of sept. While the results have been important, in passing the patriot act, congress. Section 215, which became known as the library records provision, not only allowed law enforcement agencies to secretly monitor electronic communications emanating from libraries, it also required librarians to turn over patron information if requested and even imposed a gag order on those forced to comply. Three previous reports issued in march 2007, march 2008, and may. Source document contributed to documentcloud by stephen suen propublica. Letter from civil liberties groups to house judiciary. The court ruled that the language of section 215 does not authorize bulk data collection, and no section of the patriot act does. Lynch, contains an excellent summary of the evolution of the patriot act as it relates to section 215, telephone metadata in. This white paper explains the governments legal basis for an intelligence collection. Records can include business records, library circulation records as well as publicaccess computers in public libraries see section 505 as well. Efficacy of section 215 cdr collection under the patriot act. Section 215 of the usa patriot act allows the government to obtain a secret order from the foreign.
Section 215 is often referred to as the foreign intelligence surveillance act fisa business records provision. Section 215 section 215 of the usa patriot act of 2001, which amended title v, section 501 of the foreign intelligence surveillance act fisa, access to certain business records for foreign intelligence and international terrorism investigations 50 u. What the nsa collects under section 215 of the patriot act. Section 215 of the usa patriot act of 2001, which amended title v, section 501 of the foreign. History of section 215 one patriot act amendment, section 215 of that law, expanded a provision of fisa to provide the government with broad authority to collect vast swaths of records held by businesses including in the absence of any allegation of wrongdoing. On march 15, 2020, section 215 of the patriot acta surveillance law with a rich history of government overreach and abuseexpired. Nsa reinterpreted section 215 of the patriot act in complete secrecy to allow them, with the help of the fbi, to collect millions of phone call records per day. Extension of sunset relating to individual terrorists as agents of foreign powers. That court gave congress until june 1 to clarify the language. Over the years, a series of compliance issues were brought to the attention of the fisa court by the government. Ku klux klan act, ku klux klan act 1871 julie davies the enforcement act 17 stat. Government disclosed the bulk collection of telephony metadata pursuant to section 215 of the usa patriot.
Counterintelligence and access to transactional records. Section 215 of the patriot act allows the fbi to seek orders from the. The good news is that with the end of section 215, the national security agency has lost its legal authority to collect the phone records of americans in bulk. Section 2 amended the omnibus crime control and state streets act of 1968 to allow the authorities to delay the presentation of a search warrant, if there is reasonable cause to believe that providing immediate notification of the execution of the warrant may have an adverse result usa patriot act. Congressional intent, legislative process, and section 215 of the usa patriot act christopher a. Intelligence surveillance act fisa, access to certain. Section 215 of the patriot act pdf may have expired due to congress failing to reauthorize it, but what hasnt expired is the u. Section 215 of the usa patriot act gave the fbi authority to obtain library and bookstore records and a wide range of other documents during investigations of international terrorism or secret. Report on the telephone call records program conducted. Report on the telephone records program conducted under. What would happen if patriot act section 215 expires the. Allows the director of the federal bureau of investigation. Title iusa patriot improvement and reauthorization act sec. The national security agency nsa is currently using section 215 of the patriot act 50 usc 1861 to collect the calling information of every american.
As key provisions of the patriot act come up for renewal, npr examines the acts most controversial sections. The patriot act was signed into law by president george w. Section 215, also known as the tangible things or business records provision of the usa patriot act, amended section 501 of the foreign intelligence surveillance act and permits the collection of tangible things including books. Usa patriot act title iii international money laundering abatement and antiterrorist financing act of 2001 sec. Surveillance under section 215 of the patriot actusa freedom act is complicated but affects the privacy of hundreds of millions of people. Mass surveillance under section 215 of the usa patriot act usa freedom act the fbi and nsa use section 215 to collect vast amounts of information about us persons without a warrant. Section 215 of the usa patriot act in june 20, a leaked fisa court order publicly revealed that secret interpretation. The boards report on the bulk telephone records program conducted under section 215 of the usa patriot act on the operations of the fisa court. Section 215 has come to be known as the libraries provision, even though it. The section 215 program was reauthorized most recently by the fisc on january 3, 2014. Under the second program, the government collects the content of electronic communications, including phone calls and emails, where the targets are reasonably believed to be nonu. This white paper explains the governments legal basis for an intelligence collection program under which the federal bureau of investigation fbi obtains court orders directing certain telecommunications service providers to produce telephony metadata in. Section 215 modifies the rules on records searches.
Section 215 is set to expire on june 1, and congress is now considering whether to reauthorize or amend the provision. Section 215 of the patriot act amended a provision of fisa in order to grant the government broad authority to collect vast swaths of records held by businesses including in the absence of any allegation of wrongdoing. The bill enacts significant reforms to the national security authorities that the government has used to justify collecting americans telephone records and internet metadata in bulk. Section 215 allows the government to obtain a secret court order requiring third parties, such as telephone companies, to hand over any. The language of section 215 allows for secret court orders to collect tangible things. This act may be cited as the uniting and strengthening america by providing appropriate tools required to intercept and obstruct terrorism usa patriot act act of 2001. Coalition letter on reuthorization of patriot acts.
798 1139 1501 1367 296 255 538 1466 16 769 958 406 1523 436 937 665 401 1165 250 354 329 511 143 960 1495 1306 504 42 1154 403 350 74 946 1318